types of mediation

How To Choose The Best Mediation Style

Goldberg Jones Divorce, Divorce Process, Featured Posts 1 Comment

When it comes to dissolving a marriage, many people think of intense courtroom trials, but that’s not the only option for divorce. Other tools provide alternatives, and one of the most popular and useful is mediation. Within that larger category, however, exist a number of different approaches, and it’s important to pick the best mediation style for you and your case.

What is Mediation?

Mediation is an Alternate Dispute Resolution, or ADR, which, as the name implies, provides a legal path that isn’t litigation. Used in civil suits, including divorce and child custody cases, in mediation, both sides come together in an attempt to settle the matter before them.

Facilitated by a third party, spouses use this process to reach agreements on divorce, custody, visitation, child support, and spousal support and settle most other family law matters.

It’s important to note that mediation is not legally binding. No decision is forced upon anyone and each party ultimately must accept the terms. The mediator guides and assists but doesn’t pass judgment.

When It Works Best

Because mediation is not legally binding, it works best in situations when divorcing couples are relatively amicable. Or at least they’re willing and able to play nice long enough to hammer out an agreement.

People also choose mediation because it’s often significantly cheaper, faster, and less stressful than a standard trial. In fact, many couples try mediation before heading into the courtroom. Instead of sitting in front of a judge, the process essentially boils down to a small number of people working together in an attempt to reach a common goal.

Picking The Best Style

Within the larger scope of mediation, there are multiple approaches to choose from.

You can choose from evaluative mediation, facilitative mediation, and transformative mediation. Each is a little bit different from the others and has its own set of peculiarities. The best mediation style for you depends a great deal on your circumstances and the specifics of your case. With the differences, there are situations where each may prove to be the ideal fit.

Evaluative Mediation

This approach provides spouses with a clearer understanding of what a trial might look like in their case.

The mediator uses this opportunity to demonstrate how a judge or jury might look at the specifics and even point out flaws in one party’s position.

As evaluative mediation is most similar to an actual trial, it often surfaces in civil suits like divorce. There’s room to work with conflict and former judges or attorneys who can explain the strengths and weaknesses of a particular case often serve as mediators.

In these situations, it’s common for the facilitator to put the spouses in separate rooms and jump back and forth as each side makes offers and counteroffers.

Ultimately, the aim is to meet somewhere in the middle and land on a satisfying resolution for everyone. Of the three approaches, evaluative mediation focuses primarily on the end result. The goal is to reach an agreement and avoid trial rather than spare individual interests and feelings.

If you’re simply looking for a settlement, this may be the best mediation style for you.

Facilitative Mediation

When it comes to this mediation style, the third party basically plays the role of facilitator. He or she guides spouses through the process, making sure they understand their options and the impact of their choices. Ideally, the end result is a mutually beneficial resolution both parties agree on.

In facilitative mediation, the moderator is more removed. He or she asks questions and steers the proceedings but doesn’t usually interject or make suggestions.

In the end, it falls to the spouses involved arrive at an agreement on their own accord.

This may be the best mediation style in some instances, especially when the two sides share goals. In high-conflict situations, it may not always be as effective.

Transformative Mediation

This mediation style is most common when, in addition to settling a dispute, the two sides want to address and repair problems in their relationship. While the mediator supports both parties, this strategy aims to get each side to understand the other’s needs and position.

Transformative mediation is similar in style to its facilitative cousin but differs in a few key ways. A newer approach, it’s often looked at as a touchy-feely strategy.

Using this style, the mediator is more of an enabler, helping the two parties to grow and change—to transform.

It primarily focuses on mending fences and repairing a damaged relationship rather than reaching a definite resolution. This can alleviate some of the pressure on clients, but it often leads to a longer process and less tangible results.

A transformative approach is usually the best mediation style when the participants want to preserve or salvage a relationship. If children play a part, this can be useful for parents trying to maintain civility and a future relationship for the sake of their kids.

Should You Hire A Lawyer For Mediation?

One reason many couples opt for mediation in divorce is because it doesn’t require legal counsel. Still, hiring a lawyer is worth considering. This is especially true if your spouse has an attorney as representing yourself can put you at a significant disadvantage. An experienced lawyer accompanies you to sessions and offers advice. And before you sign anything, they also make sure a settlement is fair and fits your needs.

Even if you do hire an attorney to help with mediation, the cost will almost certainly be much less than if you go to court.

Methods of dispute resolution like mediation offer an alternative to courtrooms and trials in divorce. But under that umbrella, you find a number of methods.

Some mediators subscribe to one or the other, while more use a pick-and-choose approach. The best mediation style for your case depends on the specifics of your situation, what you need, and what you hope to get out of the process.

Related Reading: Pro Se Divorce – DIY Approach
Related Reading: Is Arbitration a Better Choice?

Comments 1

  1. My uncle wants a divorce but is very nervous about going through this process on his own. I think that a mediator will be able to help and I’m glad that the end goal is always coming to a conclusion that all parties are happy with. I’ll let him know that evaluative mediation is concerned with the end goal the most.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *