Can Non-Biological Parents Win Custody?

Goldberg Jones Child Custody, Paternity 8 Comments

When you think of a family, your mind probably conjures up images of a mother, a father, a couple of kids, and that sort of thing. But families come in all shapes, sizes, and configurations. With a rising remarriage rate, new families rise from the ashes of the old.

Can You Win Custody Of A Child that isn’t technically yours?

Deep emotional connections are not exclusive to biologically linked households, but all of this, and more can complicate matters when it comes to child custody.

In the majority of cases, a biological parent will almost always have a significant advantage when it comes to gaining custody.

There are, however, situations where a non-biological parent, like a stepparent, has been awarded guardianship by the court over a blood mother or father. These situations are few and far between, and usually represent extreme circumstances, but they do exist.

When Can A Non-Biological Parent Be Granted Custody?

When it comes to custody, paramount among all other concerns is what is in the best interest of the child or children in question. The health and well-being of any minors will take precedence over pretty much anything else.

Most of the time, remaining with a biological parent will be viewed as being better for the child, but that is not always the case. If you vie for custody of a child that is not your blood relation, you will have the opportunity to present your evidence and testimony to the court.

If you can demonstrate that you are the optimal guardian, you may have a chance, though be prepared to face an uphill battle.

Perhaps the most common conditions that may lead to a non-biological parent being awarded child custody are cases of abuse, neglect, or abandonment. If it’s shown that the minor is placed in harm’s way by remaining with biological parents, it may be possible for another party to win custody.

If parents are involved in dangerous activities or criminal enterprises that may negatively impact a child, that will likely be considered. Similar to cases of abuse and neglect, a child may be removed from such situations if they are in jeopardy. When custodial parents wind up in jail or are otherwise absent, children may also be relocated.

While you may be able to gain custody by proving that the child’s biological parents are unfit, it is also possible for both sides to come to an agreement on their own outside of arbitration.

Perhaps the birth mother recognizes that she’s not the best option to care for her child and is willing to hand over custody or grant parental rights. Regular or extended visitation is also an option that you may want to explore.

Factors That Influence Custody Decisions

When it comes to determining guardianship, the court will consider a number of factors before ultimately making its decision on child custody.

  • The age of the child or children in question may figure into the final ruling.
  • The older the child, the more meaningful a bond he or she may have formed with a non-biological parent, and this may be accounted for.
  • If a child is old enough, he or she may be able to voice an opinion on the matter.
  • Though the court may take this into account, a judge will ultimately act in the child’s best interest. Even if that runs counter to the expressed wishes.

Along these lines, the court may very well consider the nature of the relationship between the non-biological parent and the child.

  • If the bond is deep, meaningful, and beneficial, that may factor into the decision.
  • If you have acted like a father, that may go a long way to strengthening your case.
  • Raising a child from a very young age, paying child support, and generally looking after their health and well-being like a great parent.

Keep in mind that the child’s best interests are paramount and that long, drawn-out court battles may not be ideal. Hopefully, you and the other parties involved will be able to come to a peaceable accord.

Comments 8

  1. My son and daughter in law are in a custody dispute with the wife of my daughter in law brother he passed away 2 weeks ago. They were not divorced but separated for 3 1/2 years and the mother had never had anything to do with the kids until he passed away . There is money involved social security and life insurance left to the grandma as beneficiary. The mother has been said to have been involved in drugs i am just saying what I heard. When my son and wife showed up at court the mother did not have to show up because she had made a court date on the same date and time as the other one don’t know how that works. I know where the boys belong and where they want to be but seems like an uphill battle against the judicial system and a lawyer that didn’t do a very good job and no arguing whatsoever on my son and his wife’s account. I’m just wanting to know what can they do to have a chance of getting these kids back where they can be in a stable home what is your advise.

    1. Post

      Hi Leslie,
      Thanks for reaching out. That’s a tough, complicated situation. I passed your contact information along to Ken Alan, our managing attorney. He will reach out soon and give you a clearer idea of your options.

  2. I have 2 cars both gifted to me during our marriage and I have 2 kids who think he is their daddy they don’t know anyone else. Can you give me a little bit of advice of what will happen. I live in indiana.

    1. Post

      Hi Tiffanie, thanks for reaching out. That’s a tricky situation. I passed your contact information on to Ken Alan, our managing attorney. He will reach out to you soon and hopefully give you a better idea of your options.

    1. Post

      That’s a tough situation, Jami. Thanks for reaching out. I passed your contact information along to our managing attorney, Ken Alan. He will get in touch soon with a better answer than we can get into here.

  3. Hello! My husband is about to join the military and obviously we would be moving around a bit, however wed have to take my daughters biological father to court for full custody. How high are the chances of us getting full custody? I’m a stay at home mom and my husband has been there for my daughter since day one. She and he have formed this amazing bond and she has no idea who her biological father is. She thinks my husband is her one and only daddy. Please let me know if my chances are good or not.

    1. Post

      Hi Caitlyn, thanks for reaching out. Custody cases depend on a lot of factors and can get complicated in a hurry. I passed your contact information on to our managing attorney. He will be in touch soon and hopefully be able to give you an idea of your options and chances!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *